Posted Friday 10/10/2008 1:40 PM in
BFG by Gerasimos Manolatos
Filed under: Weird, Wii For Dummies, Joystiq, Wii
Look—you're awesome, Joystiq's Kyle Orland. Really. You're smart, you're entertaining, and sometimes, after seven or eight beers, you kinda look like MSNBC's Chris Matthews. But, in the mighty words of Martin's Shanaenae: Oh no you diiint.
Arriving on our entertainment editor's unsuspecting desk was this: Wii for Dummies. Clad in the now world-famous black and yellow design template, the book covers all of the basics of unboxing, hooking up, and playing Nintendo's popular console.
The thing is, well, there's already a book for Wii owners: the instruction manual. If you've got $21.99 to withhold throwing into a fireplace, you can find out how to create a Mii character, look at photos, use the Internet, and two pages—I shit you not—on how to point your Wii controller at your TV. To think that they cleared forests somewhere to make this book has me almost caring about the environment!
The more puzzling thing is that the console is a popular staple among the five-year-old crowd (yes, I said it, live with it), so a book geared toward humans with intelligence below that threshold leaves us facepalmingly stupefied. Case in point, an excerpt from page 207 that explains how to play Wii Baseball:
"For the pitcher, the goal is to strike out the batter by throwing the ball over the plate in a way that's hard to hit. For the batter, the goal is to hit the ball, putting it in play in fair territory (inside the angled white lines) so that it lands safely in the outfield (the grassy area) without getting caught in mid-air. This is a base hit, which puts a runner on base."
No child left behind, indeed.
EDIT: We've clarified the attribution of the book to Kyle Orland, who writes for Joystiq and has written the book independent from his work on the site. If there's anyone who can tell you how to turn your WIi on, it's him.
| MOST RECENT COMMENTS | |
| Posted by Kyle Orland on 10/12/2008 12:22 PM | report abuse |
|
Fair criticisms of the book, I suppose, though I'd argue that the book goes a little farther than the instruction manuals in covering recommended games and accessories, tips/tricks and hints for popular games, the history of Nintendo and the Wii, etc. It's not for everyone, but I'd like to think the plain, conversational style will be a little easier for new gamers to digest than the technical manuals included with the system/games. That said, there's no reason to bring Joystiq into this. Yes, I do write blog posts over there (as indicated on the book cover), but my work on Wii for Dummies was totally independent of my work for Joystiq. The book was commissioned by Wiley publishing, not AOL/Joystiq. In your words, they actually "diint." Leave them out of this.
|
|
| Posted by Gerasimos Manolatos on 10/12/2008 2:18 PM | report abuse |
|
Thanks for responding Kyle. While we clearly have differing opinions on the value of the book, we agree that there is a call out to your contributions on Joystiq on the cover of the book. Once you identify yourself from a publication, you are then a representative of that publication as a whole.
|
|
|
|
|