Elisha Cuthbert, who charmed us from The Girl Next Door all the way to the prematurely canceled Happy Endings, made her return to television last night with One Big Happy. She plays Lizzy, a lesbian who decides to have a baby with her best friend Luke. Thing is, he falls in love with another woman just as Lizzy discovers she’s pregnant. To celebrate Cuthbert’s return to the small screen, we’re looking back at our favorite photos of her.
Photos by Photographed for Maxim by John Russo