V is for Vicki…and Virgin: Tara launched her career as Vicki in American Pie by playing hard to get with her sex-craved boyfriend. And who could blame him? After she finally gave in, she broke it off before college. We were nearly as heartbroken as Kevin until she turned up even hotter in American Pie 2. But for the sake of the third-generation Stifler in American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile, we can only hope the newest Pie girls have learned from Vicky's mistakes.