When Khloe Kardashian agreed to participate in James Corden's "Spill Your Guts or Fill Your Guts" challenge, she thought she'd be subjected to the usual questions — relatively innocent items like "Which celebrity has been rude to you?" or "What's the most annoying thing about your sisters?"
If Khloe pleaded the fifth on any one of the questions, she would then have to eat one of the sickening "foods" the English funnyman had laid out, like cod sperm, bird saliva and fish eyes.
The first question was innocuous enough, but Corden followed up with a doozy. To avoid guzzling down a fish eye, Khloe was asked "Do you think OJ did it?"
The crowd gasped, and Corden turned beet red after reading the cue card.
Above, see how Khloe dealt with the celebrity talk show equivalent to Sophie's Choice. Did she turn against the memory of her father Robert Kardashian, the late attorney who famously served on OJ Simpson's defense team during his 1995 murder trial, or chow down on that slimy fish eye?