I Hooked Up With My Best Friend’s Brother, and She Can Never Find Out

What she doesn’t know can’t hurt her.

Ever have a story so hot it would be wrong not to share it with the rest of the world? We’re here to listen. Each week, we’ll bring you tempting tales from our readers that will definitely keep you up all night—in the best way possible. This time, Stacey*  tells us about the one sex secret she can never share with her best friend.

How did you know him?

Well, I’ve known the guy’s sister since I was 15, so we’ve been friends for a really long time. Every time I would go over there, her older brother would be a little flirty with me and I would flirt back, but I never really thought anything of it.

So where did this all go down?

We were celebrating my best friend’s birthday, which makes it even worse. But that night I drank a lot of tequila, and for whatever reason, he and I were alone in a room just talking.

Just talking?

I can’t even remember what we were talking about, but he kept saying how much he wanted to hook up with me. And I was like, “I would never do that to my best friend”.

Well that didn’t last long.

Yeah. She came into the room at the end of the night to tell us that everyone was going to bed, and to make sure to be quiet and keep our conversation down. We were obviously just talking. Then out of nowhere, a couple minutes later, he pushed me up against a wall and we just started making out. It was literally like a scene from a movie. There wasn’t any foreplay, we just ripped our clothes off and started going at it.

That seems pretty sudden. Did you have any sexual tension in the past?

I didn’t think so. I guess I never found him super attractive, to this day. It was just kind of like… he was there!

Seriously, that was the only reason?

Well, I had been reading a lot about sex at the time, but I wasn’t getting any, so it was just building up and he happened to be there. We literally just started tearing each other’s clothes off—it was so hot. I just remember the next day thinking, “Oh my God, what did I do?”

But what were you thinking as it was happening?

I was just going with the flow. It was amazing. I was so in the moment. It was so hot and everything just stopped. It was the perfect hookup. Afterwards, I was freaking out. The next day was the 4th of July, I didn’t even go outside. I felt so guilty about what I did.

Well, did anything weird happen that day?

I texted him the next morning because I didn’t want to go upstairs and talk to him about it. So I just sent him a message like “No one can know about what happened, at all” because I really didn’t want to ruin my relationship with my best friend. I knew she would be really, really upset. And he said “As far as I’m concerned, last night didn’t happen.” So he didn’t tell anyone, I didn’t tell anyone. It’s just a total secret.

What do you think would happen if your friend found out?

Well, our friendship would never be the same. I have to keep this secret from her forever, which totally sucks, but at the same time it kind of made it hotter.

Sometimes we just can’t help ourselves!

After a week or two I was like “It is what it is,” I can’t really dwell on it anymore. But I felt really bad for a while. And I still feel a little bad about it. If I had told my friend I liked her brother, I think she would be okay with it. But I don’t think she’d be okay with it being, like, just a one night stand!

*Names have been changed

Have a story you think we should hear? Click here for a chance to be featured on Maxim. Read more Sex Life stories here.

Photos by Linka A. Odom / Getty Images